Technical Guide

Coiled Tubing vs Workover Rig: Which Do You Need?

Both coiled tubing units and workover rigs are used for well intervention, but they are designed for different jobs. Choosing the wrong one can cost you time and money. Here is a practical comparison to help you decide.

What Is a Workover Rig?

Workover Rig: Pulling and Running Tubing

A workover rig (also called a pulling unit or service rig) is designed to pull and run tubing in and out of the wellbore. It uses a drawworks and a mast to lift and lower jointed tubing (usually 27 or 30 feet per joint).

Best for:

  • Pulling and running production tubing
  • Pump changes and rod replacement
  • Plug setting and retrieval
  • General well servicing where you need to pull tubing

Strengths: High pull force (up to 1500 kN), can handle large tubing sizes, relatively low cost per day, familiar technology for most crews.

Limitations: Cannot run under pressure (needs to kill the well), slow because you have to make and break joints, cannot reach horizontal sections easily.

What Is Coiled Tubing?

Coiled Tubing Unit: Intervention Under Pressure

A coiled tubing unit uses a continuous string of steel tubing wound on a reel. The tubing is fed into the well through an injector head, which pushes and pulls the coil. Because the tubing is continuous, there are no joints to make or break.

Best for:

  • Well intervention under pressure (live well)
  • Sand cleanout and solids removal
  • Acidizing and chemical stimulation
  • Logging and logging-while-drilling in horizontal wells
  • Milling and plug removal

Strengths: Can run under pressure (no need to kill the well), fast deployment (no joints to make/break), can reach horizontal and deviated sections, smaller footprint.

Limitations: Lower pull force (typically 60–150 kN), smaller tubing diameter, higher day rate, more specialized crew training required.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Which One Should You Choose?

Here is a quick comparison to help you decide:

Choose Workover Rig If:

Workover Rig is the Right Choice

  • You need to pull and run production tubing
  • The well can be killed safely
  • You have deep wells with heavy tubing strings
  • Cost per day is a major factor
  • Your crew is familiar with conventional rig operations
Choose Coiled Tubing If:

Coiled Tubing is the Right Choice

  • You need to intervene on a live well (under pressure)
  • You need to clean out sand or scale from the wellbore
  • You have horizontal or highly deviated wells
  • Speed is important (CT rigs are faster for most interventions)
  • You need to place chemicals or acid precisely
Common Scenarios

What Do Operators Usually Use?

In most mature oilfields, operators use both. Workover rigs handle the heavy work —pulling tubing, changing pumps, running completion components. Coiled tubing units handle the lighter, faster interventions —cleanouts, acid jobs, logging.

For shale and tight oil development, coiled tubing is especially important because of the horizontal wells. You cannot easily run jointed tubing through a lateral section —coiled tubing is the standard approach for plug milling and cleanout in horizontal wells.

For shallow stripper wells, workover rigs are usually the better economic choice. The lower day rate and simpler operation make them cost-effective for routine servicing.